I really enjoyed Proud of You Tobacco so I decided to pick this up to compare. Tbh I don’t get much of the tobacco in this. Slightly more synthetic smelling and weaker than POY. Hopefully looking to get the actual OG soon once I find it available.

picked this up as a fan of the Stronger With You line, and the DNA is definitely there. To my nose, it opens with a noticeable "cherry tobacco" vibe that sets it apart. While it doesn't quite reach the same depth or quality as the original SWY Tobacco, it’s a very solid alternative for the price.
​Presentation: The bottle is decent, but the standout is the pressurized atomizer—it gives a really nice, controlled spray which is rare at this price point.
​Occasion: This feels like an elevated scent. I’d wear this for a nice evening out or a second/third date. It’s perfect for a "business casual" look—think chinos and a polo rather than blue jeans and a tee.
​Performance: Moderate. It’s not a beast, but it holds its own for an evening. If you want that sweet, tobacco warmth without the designer price tag, this is a great bet.

This was a blind purchase, but it worked out so so well. This smells absolutely amazing. My wife can’t get enough when I wear this scent.

Very nice quality